Catholic Journal for Girls vs Boys: Which to Choose

Quick answer

Choose the Be Yourself! journal for Catholic girls if your daughter responds to saint role models and reflective writing. Pick the version for Catholic boys if your son needs a more active, identity-focused approach grounded in papal teaching.

How to decide: decision rules

• If your child responds to saint stories: Pick the girls' journal. The seven female saints provide varied role models for different personalities and struggles.
• If your child needs to hear they matter as an individual: Choose the boys' journal. The John Paul II quote and identity focus directly address that need.
• If you're still unsure about writing readiness: Both journals include quizzes and artwork, so even a reluctant writer can engage. The girls' edition has more open-ended prompts; the boys' edition has more guided questions. Consider your child's comfort with open-ended writing vs. structured activities.

Product facts

• Be Yourself! A Journal for Catholic Girls: Includes inspirational quotes from seven female saints, passages from the Catechism and Scripture, and beautiful artwork. Gives girls concrete saint examples to connect with, making faith exploration feel personal and relatable.

  

• Be Yourself! A Journal for Catholic Boys: Features a quote from Pope Saint John Paul II and focuses on understanding identity and individuality through Catholic teaching. Helps boys see their unique worth in God's eyes, which can be especially powerful during the pre-teen years.

  

Fit guidance

Best for

• A tween or teen girl who enjoys journaling and wants saint companions
• A tween or teen boy who needs affirmation of his unique God-given identity

Not for

• A child who strongly dislikes any written reflection (try a prayer card or saint medal instead)